Squatting, It’s Not a Yoga Position


squatters-in-costa-rica-1I swore I wouldn’t post anything on my blog about squatters and squatting until our interminable legal case has been tried and a verdict rendered, but I couldn’t help myself this morning, and besides our case may outlive the Dickens’ Jarndyce v Jarndyce so I might as well forge ahead.

Squatting in Costa Rica is a national sport. Of our five neighbors, three are actively involved in the  activity, two directly with us.

The idea stems from something called adverse possession and grew from an egalitarian constitutional law when Costa Rica formed its fledgling democracy in 1949. The squatter laws were designed to allow poor landless farmers to settle and work unoccupied land and claim it for themselves. The idea— good in theory— was to prevent oligarchic forces from holding large tracts of land leaving the majority of the population scratching out a living as landless laborers.

Known here as “precaristas,” squatters can begin to acquire rights to the land in as little as three months. After a year, they can take proof of occupancy to the titling agency, the Agriculture Development Institute (IDA), and have the land declared in conflict. If that happens, IDA can force the previous landowner to sell the land to the precaristas.

All this is well and good; everyone deserves to have a place to live. However, as land values have increased and the population has grown, developers have entered the arena and hired professional squatters to camp out on people’s land, eventually forcing a sale at a reduced rate. It is a nasty business.

But that is really not what I was going to write about. It appears the behavior of squatting is creeping north, like killer bees, or perhaps the United States is becoming Latin American, not only in minority demographics but also in attitude.

Here is the flip-side of the squatter argument as it relates to one Andre “Loki Boy” Barbosa, a Brazilian who has recently occupied a vacant mansion in Boca Raton, Florida. You can read about it here but essentially he moved into a vacant 2.5 million dollar mansion, a foreclosure property owned by The Bank of America.mansion-squatter

Apparently Florida has an adverse possession law on the books, and on December 26th Loki Boy turned on the lights and declared he was in possession of the property. The police have been unable to legally remove him and, according to news reports, he is within his rights to be in the house. The neighbors are fit to be tied.

But here is the interesting part. It turns out that Bank of America has kept this particular house off the market to artificially drive up housing prices in a weak market. With fewer houses of this calibre actively for sale, the theory goes, the bank is driving the real estate market and the so-called housing recovery. Here is an interesting website talking about the phony recovery and all the houses that are now stashed in the wings, a method known as foreclosure stuffing. The banks, who got a minor wrist slap for their part in the robo-foreclosures of the housing debacle, it appears are now manipulating the rebound. Meanwhile they are leaving houses vacant.

The New Oligarchs.

So hats off, Loki Boy. It has certainly brought to light some very ugly things about the “housing recovery.”

Sadly, today’s news reports he has been issued an eviction order.

Our squatters? In 2009 we obtained a restraining order from the agricultural court and are currently mired in the legal process, which could be described as a workout at your local gym. Like any good session on a  Nautilus machine, the undertaking stresses the body and mind just to the breaking point before relinquishing enough satisfaction to bring us back for another round.

Published by SC Morgan

I grew up in Oregon and learned not everything is black and white. Now I live in the jungles of Costa Rica where the shades of gray cover the full spectrum. I shoot my mouth off on my blog, social media sites, and sometimes I get published. You can find my blog here: https://scmorgancom.wordpress.com/

5 thoughts on “Squatting, It’s Not a Yoga Position

  1. Sorry for the inconvenience, but my site was compromised yesterday, and my hosting service, Bluehost, shut it down. We have been in contact this morning, fixed the security issue (a corrupted theme) and the blog should be back up and running. Cannot say enough good things about the people over at Bluehost. They work like dogs and purr like contented cats, always efficient, friendly, and competent.


  2. Bluehost sound a great bunch! Lovely to be able to give a compliment, isn’t it.

    British banks are busy foreclosing on business premises…hotels in particular….in order to boost their assets ahead of a revue of banking reserves. No way are these going on the market….so they’ll sit and moulder at exaggerated values on their books.

    We’re currently over two years into getting a concession from MINAET to access water from a spring on a neighbouring…American owned…property.

    Never have so many managed to lose so few papers so often…..


  3. It is, indeed, a pleasure to be able to give a heartfelt compliment to a company doing good work. Reminds me of your paint store story.

    I finally took all my money out of the stock market when I realized I could not trust the market, the ratings agencies, not to mention the traders. I see they are still up to their tricks and the media covers it all as though it were real. If I had any money left, I’d bury it under a log or my mattress.

    Don’t even get me started about MINAET. They are the ones who gave our neighbor, Jon Kalina, permission to build a hotel in the Gandoca-Manzanillo Refuge, then reneged after it was completed. The battle lasted 20 years and ended with them tearing down the hotel. Kalina died of complications due to alcohol a month later.


  4. Well, we’ve gone through three directors of the water division of MINAET, had one hint (not from MINAET) that a bribe would fix it (no, we didn’t)…have been shown the folder’s process on the computer…except it can’t be the one MINAET actually use….have had shutdown of communication and finally kicked things into action again by going to the offices every week…at which point a legal point was raised and kicked into touch…….then off to the Controlaria de Servicios of MINAET…now the folder is supposed to have gone for final signature….but I’m not holding my breath….

    The next battle (if and when we get that far) will be gaining entry to our neighbour’s land to do the work….


    1. What is the old saying? When you come to Costa Rica, come with your pockets full– one full of patience, the other full of money. I have ceased to balk at the “informal payment” options. We haven’t done it but I wonder if it’s wise to ignore it. My head hurts from banging it against the wall of Justice. Sounds like you have an uphill battle in front of you…. depending on your neighbor, of course. People here are pretty leery of access, and for good reason I might add.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: